Monday, April 7, 2014

Queries on AAP Manifesto

I went through the Manifesto of the AAP, the only one I have gone through yet. I have some queries related to it, hoping that someone from the party will be able answer these. Quite late probably, but I still have 10 days before my city goes to vote. The numbering of points is not necessarily as per the numbers in the manifesto. These are numbered as per questions that arose in my mind.

I also have certain queries which are not related to things mentioned in the manifesto, but about some issues on which the party or its members have taken stand against. These are there at the end.

1.            JanLokpal:

This has been a major point that the AAP has been aiming at. The full plan of the Jan Lokpal is not known to me yet. Is this available somewhere on the internet for analysis and scrutiny? It somehow feels like it relies on the incorruptibility of individuals. How would a nation of corrupt people produce a person for one incorruptible position? The Lokpal seems to have control over all organizations, but who has the power to initiate investigation against Lokpal? How do we hold the Lokpal accountable?

2.            Time-bound Investigation:

While it is always good to have investigation being timed, but can we really and practically do this? Wouldn't there be a higher risk of insufficient and hurried investigation in this case? How do you strike a balance between quick investigation and thorough investigation? What happens if sufficient information is not gathered in the timeframe provided?

3.            Gram and Mohalla Sabhas:

  a)          How do we govern these sabhas? What rules will they be bound by and what will their jurisdiction be?
b)            This sounds more like majority rule rather than democracy. Ex: if a majority wants to build a temple, church or mosque using government funds, will that be allowed. If a minority of the sabha members have strict opposition to a decision taken, how will that be handled?
c)            How do you ensure no bribes work in the gram sabha offices? How do you ensure proper procedure and checks are followed before issuance of certificates? What checks and balances will be in place?
d)            How do you ensure that these gram sabhas are not held just on paper, but happen in reality and also how do you ensure that people actually are aware of this? As heard recently on Satyamev Jayate, in Bihar gram sabhas are held on paper alone people are made to sign with their ration as hostage.

4.            Gram Nyayalays:

What would be the difference between these and the regular nyayalays? would these have additional judicial powers? Would these be independent of regular judiciary? Would they be something like a Khap Panchayat? How do we ensure such Nyayalays do not breach the constitution and the law? Would there be lawyers in these nyayalays?

5.            Policing:

a)            How would keeping people in Judicial custody help anyone?
b)            How do you plan to handle non-registering of FIR? Whom should people complain to?

6.            Election Commission:

a)            Selection of commissioners: How would that constitutional committee be formed?
b)            Advertisement and TV space: I agree regarding public money aspect, but should the rest really be curbed? Should it not be a free country? Also, how would you track paid news, as opposed to news based on personal bias? Of course news should be impersonal but since it no longer is, how exactly would paid news and personally biased news appear different?
c)            Proportional Representation: Is this ideal, considering that parties from UP, Bihar and some such heavily populated states will have more representation than some states such as Kerala which has very less population.
d)            Right to Recall and Right to Reject: Please elaborate on what you mean by right to reject and explain how you plan to avoid misuse of Right To Recall as a blackmail tool.

7.            Healthcare:

a)            How do you intend to ensure quality medical care irrespective of monitory status? Do you give free treatment in private hospitals or implement something like an insurance scheme? Or is it going to be something like the NHS system of UK. You should probably explore this option.
b)            Homeopathy etc.: According to majority of scientific community these are unreliable methods and unscientific methods which dupe people of real treatment. Before investing further on these, do we intend to get these methods scientifically validated by performing proper investigation and studies before investing public money into any more facilities in these streams?

8.            Education:

a)            I am completely against democratising education. The world has enough people who do not care about truth or science and would rather teach blabberdash to students. Please leave education to educators rather than gram and muhalla sabhas. Ex: If the muhalla sabha decides that pupils should not be taught that the sun is a star around which earth rotates, would that be approved?

9.            Improving farmer's livelihood:

a)            Would it not be better for the farmers to be allowed to choose the price themselves rather than the government fixing it?
b)            What is the problem with genetically modified food? The larger scientific community says that it is not harmful, so what basis do you form to claim that it is harmful? What is the basis for this? We all know that over time we have produced genetically altered produce in natural ways by cross pollination and many such methods that I do not recollect now. Why does it sound a bit jingoistic?

10.          Gender Justice:

a)            Women's reservation: Is there a target set for the removal of this reservation? What would indicate that reservation is no longer required? At present there are at least some prominent women politicians who do not need any reservation, doesn't this mean that what is needed is not reservation but rather having stronger women candidates? Would you prefer to have a weaker member in parliament in the name of reservation or grooming a female as a strong candidate?
b)            You do not mention anything about the third gender, transsexuals etc. What is your policy going to be for these who are the most discriminated for their gender.

11.          Security and Non-discrimination for Muslims:

a)            Waqf properties: Would something similar also be introduced for the Hindu temples of the pre-independence era?

12.          Adivasis Taking Charge Of Their Development:

a)            Gram Sabhas deciding on forest land: What if they decide to raze the forest and create farms there? What rules govern these?

13.          Animal Welfare:

a)            Regulations of industries using animals for food etc.: Is this another way of saying you will make India vegetarian? Please elaborate.

14.          Media Policy:

a)            Paid news: How do you differentiate between paid news and personal judgement of the anchor?

15.          Defence Policy:

a)            Weapons development: How do you encourage research in this field? Do you encourage private players or find ways to motivate DRDO to actually research stuff?
b)            ECHS: How do you ensure ECHS is actually worthy? Their doctors are overworked with hardly any time to spend examining patients. When they refer to private dentists, they refer at random to clinics where trainees do a pathetic job (both from personal family experience).

Additional Queries:

1.            Nuclear Energy:

After witnessing mister AK protest the Kudankulam reactor and the main person behind the protest being a member of the party, I really would like to know what is your agenda about this? As has been widely discussed, India's energy requirements are too high to be fulfilled entirely based on renewable resources in the near future. Also, nuclear reactors pollute lesser than the carbon based fuel generators. Considering these, should you not in fact support nuclear reactors for the time being? A country like Japan has been almost entirely powered by nuclear power for a good majority of the time and there was one incident. US majorly draws power from nuclear reactors, no incident so far. India already has nuclear reactors, no accidents so far. France is primarily powered by nuclear reactors. Considering that world-over there are more than 100 reactors and only 2 incidents, isn't it a bit paranoid to fight against nuclear energy, especially in an energy starved nation like India?

2.           Jan Lokpal Failure:

If the AAP wins majority in the parliament, but still fails to pass the Jan Lokpal bill because all other parties and some people from AAP objected to it, what will be the plan of action for the party? Would you dissolve the party again because you are not here for power, or would you continue to work on all other aspects while finding an alternative to the Jan Lokpal?

3.           Good vs. Majority decision

Majority of India's Aam Aadmi is against sex education, but most academia in India and abroad agree that this is a really important education to be imparted to children. Considering the majority of Aam Aadmi has objection to this, what will Aam Aadmi Party do about this?

4.           Awareness

A lot of ideas in the manifesto require grass root level awareness campaigns. For example, getting reservation to the deserving. How would you go about this?


5.           Empowering People

How do you empower a gram sabha with members who lack awareness or a sense of responsibility?